Pre-Finale Recap: Observations on Cultural InequityApril 11, 2009There's so much to say about the finale, reunion and RuPaul's Drag Race in general that I've been procrastinating because the task feels monumental. However as RPDR is one of the
Top Five Best TV Shows Ever, I feel I owe it its due diligence.
Prepare to be here a while, because this is gonna be a long couple of posts. I'll break them up, but consider yourselves warned.
Before I recap, I've been mulling this over for ~two months and I haven't yet been able to articulate it. Bear with me as I muddle through. I'd like an open and constructive talk about this.
Let's take a philosophical look at the relative "cost/reward" benefit of many so-called "Competitive Reality" shows. I think it encapsulates a huge societal inequity which I find patently unfair and unwarranted.
America's Next Top Model: Each cycle they roll out a new batch of anorexic and overwhelmingly vapid screeching harpies.
Yes, there are a few exceptions-I acknowledge it. Nonetheless, each cycle gets progressively more astonishing in lowering the proverbial bar. Meanwhile,
Tyra's narcissism increases, impossible as that seems.
Winner-take-all grand prize: $100,000 USD
Project Runway: Ah, my first reality show love. I was smitten from the moment I saw Austin Scarlett and Jay McCarroll in the "coming soon" ads. I suppose I always will be, even though my love affair has cooled somewhat in more recent seasons. Bless
BPR, they still put up with me, answer my emails and link to this blog when I recap. I don't have much general criticism of the show except that due to litigiousness we've been denied S6, but that's a post for another day. The challenges are difficult, and I will grant that contestants for the most part (obligatory low-hanging fruit excepted) are talented. And...
The Divine Tim Gunn. '
Nuff said. Regardless,
winner-take-all grand prize: $100,000 USD.Top Chef: More of the same, just with food as opposed to fashion. It's no Project Runway, and Tom
Collichio isn't in the same
trophic layer as Tim
Gunn (but who is? Did I mention I adore Tim
Gunn? Just checking). I do appreciate that most individuals on the show are normal-sized human beings. But again,
winner-take-all grand prize: $100,000 USD.There are more examples, but you see my point.
RuPaul's Drag Race:
Grand Prize: $20,000 USD. One fifth. Twenty percent.Look, wherever you land on the GLBT tolerance spectrum, if you OBJECTIVELY evaluate some basic criteria,
RPDR's contestants got a raw deal. Don't get me wrong; I'm not dissing the show; quite the contrary, in fact.
Those individuals have spent the better part of their lives overcoming narrow-mindedness from every direction, even within their own community. They endured hatred, bigotry, criticism from every angle and have shined in spite of all the negativity thrown at them. They arrived on set with their wardrobes and makeup kits, most of which I'm sure cost a
fortune. It's not like most dudes can buy fabulous drag outfits off-the-rack at
TJ Maxx and Nine West; much of the clothing is custom, and
man-sized stilettos aren't sold just
anywhere.
The challenges in RPDR were in many ways as difficult, sometimes I assert MORE difficult than other reality shows. Their deadlines were always incredibly short. Furthermore, not only did they have to prepare for the task at hand, they had to factor in:
- Shaving, hiding tattoos, feminizing and essentially 'reinventing' themselves;
- Doing their own makeup and hair;
- Assembling or sewing their entire look;
- Accessorizing;
- Doing the challenge itself - which robs them of precious prep time; AND
- Preparing a lip-sync routine in case they were in the bottom two at judging.
Come on, folks. Those bitches worked HARD. They had to transform themselves using all kinds of props and tucks--these aren't standard or insignificant variables. With regard to ANTM, the extent of their prep was showing up on time and throwing tantrums about the stylists' work. Give me a frigging break.
Let's set all of that aside and put the rest on a hypothetical equal footing. To wit, contestants (
ANTM N00bz excepted) are Subject Matter Experts and cooking, sewing/fashion and drag challenges all lie within every contestant's RELATIVE comfort zones. Given that assumption, maybe the RPDR challenges weren't orders of magnitude harder than the other shows. Though it seemed that way from my view in the cheap seats.
But look at the risk/reward ratio. I assert that these individuals are working harder, and putting themselves out to a higher level of public scrutiny than their counterparts. They had to arrive at the competition with custom wardrobes that undoubtedly cost *thousands* (ok, maybe not self-professed 'Cheap Ho' Akashia, but generally my point holds). Everyone comes out of the experience with public exposure, which has pluses
and minuses. Bebe Benet Zahara came out of it with $20k. I'm willing to bet that Nina, Bebe, Ongina and Shannel spent much more than that just to get there, so
financially speaking it's a net loss.
Yet the grand prize payoff is 20% of the rest of the shows. It's paltry considering what they had to spend (financially and psychologically) just to GET there.
Is it that Logo (or their sponsor, Absolut) doesn't have deep pockets? Clearly not.
I'm not an idiot. I know drag is considered a niche and doesn't have the same "wide appeal." But why is that? These drag queens are
artists. Why are they not more appreciated and valued in general society? Does drag have to become mainstream before we demonstrate that it
deserves parity?
It frustrates me. Ok, yes, even $100k isn't much these days, but honestly, that's not the point. It's the message being sent and perpetuated.
Watch some of the interviews and confessionals of many ANTM model-wannabes. Vapid isn't strong enough, but I'm at a loss for a better word. Most are incredibly dumb. In many cases, they're completely unaware about even the industry for which they profess having passion. And when it comes to worldliness, just...OMG. Even considering "creative editing" the bulk of these girls have no political or social awareness, are not articulate, and I'd argue that some have a total lack of talent. Yeah, I know; who am I to judge. But watching ANTM is NOT mind-expanding television. I periodically watch the (endless) ANTM marathons out of sheer morbid curiosity.
With the exception of Akashia, none of the drag queens on RPDR came off on the show as oblivious or inarticulate. And
ALL of them had talent. Nina Flowers, bless her heart, was FAR too hard on herself when referring to the language barrier and her accent. It wasn't a liability, it's part of her charm. I'm not saying that as a sycophantic fan. Public reaction to Nina speaks for itself; we were ALL charmed by her. The periodic language 'barrier' never diminished how intelligent, worldly or kind she seemed.
I just think that given the monumental challenges these contestants had to go through, it should be AT LEAST equally valued and rewarded like the other shows of the same category. The Logo network and the sponsors are sending the wrong message by trying to "get out cheaper." In other words, it communicates--to me at least--that Logo is shooting themselves in the foot. They profess to fight for parity, but it's just lip service. Literally--put your money where your mouth is. If your mission is to widen acceptance, then model good behavior and treat everyone equally.
The GLBT and allied communities are fighting for equality. True parity in American society. And rightfully so. I say let's start DEMONSTRATING it.
I'm going to leave the comments open on this post because I'm TRULY curious to hear peoples' thoughts. I reserve the right to delete hatred, bigotry and bile-spewing. But if you've read this far and you have some constructive thoughts, share them here. Let's talk.
Recaps of the finale and the reunion to come soon. I wanted to get this post out first.
Thanks,
-ScubaOtter
Labels: ANTM, Fashion, Observations, Peeves, Pop Culture, Project Runway, RuPaul's Drag Race, TV